べきではない

JLPT N3approx.Neutral
Meaning
  1. 1States as a general moral principle that an action is wrong and should not be done.Ex. 1
  2. 2Advises or criticizes that a particular behavior is inappropriate in a given situation or toward certain people.Ex. 2
Formation
Verb (dictionary form)+べきではない言うべきではない
する→すべきではないするべきではない
Noun / na-adj.+であるべきではない (less common)Variant: べきでない; Polite: べきではありません; Past: べきではなかった, meaning "should not have"
Examples
人ひとの悪口わるぐちを言ゆうべきではない。
You shouldn't speak ill of others.
親おやの前まえでそんな失礼しつれいな態度たいどを取とるべきではない。
You shouldn't take such a rude attitude in front of your parents.
Usage

Used in both speech and writing to state firm opinions about right and wrong, such as manners, ethics and social norms. It reflects the speaker's own judgment rather than an official rule, so it is weaker than てはならない. It is also softer than direct prohibitions like てはいけない.

Watch out

Do not attach べき to the ない-form; say 言うべきではない, not 言わないべきだ.

Note that with する the contracted form すべきではない is very common alongside するべきではない.

Learners should note that saying this directly to a superior can sound preachy or like a lecture.

Easily confused with
  • べきN3「べき」expresses an affirmative 'should', can end a sentence as 「べきだ」, and can also modify a noun as 「べき+noun」; 「べきではない」is its negative form with the opposite meaning, and the two are not interchangeable. Note that 「〜ないべき」is not used.
  • ものではないN2「ものではない」has a similar admonishing sense and can be interchangeable, but it gives general admonitions based on social common sense with a more tactful tone, often used when elders lecture; it also has a 'was never possible' sense and can attach to the potential form of a verb.
  • てはならないN2「てはならない」attaches to the て-form of a verb and is a formal, written 'must not', used both for explicit prohibitions in rules and laws and for moral admonition. On the moral level it is close in meaning to this pattern, but its tone is more severe, and it is rarely used in everyday speech.
  • てはいけないN5「てはいけない」is a direct prohibition, mostly used in rules, notices, and warnings to children and students, and can also indicate that a state is unacceptable; 「べきではない」focuses on what should not be done by reason, expressing assertions or criticism, and is generally not used in notices or regulations.
  • 〜ないほうがいいN4「〜ないほうがいい」is advice based on pros and cons with a soft tone; 「べきではない」is a judgment that something 'should not' be done by reason, which is weightier, and it can also criticize others and express regret with 「べきではなかった」. The former attaches to the ない-form.
  • まじきN1「まじき」is literary written language with harsher condemnation, usually only modifying nouns, often in the form 「にあるまじき」to denounce behavior unbefitting one's position; 「べきではない」is neutral in register, can end a sentence, and is also used for admonition or to express regret.

べき is the affirmative "should"; ものではない appeals to general common sense in a softer, admonishing way; てはならない is a stronger, more formal prohibition often tied to rules. てはいけない is a direct everyday prohibition, 〜ないほうがいい is gentle advice, and まじき is a literary form used before nouns for conduct unbecoming one's role.

Grammar · JLPT grammar levels are community estimates, not official (no official lists have been published since the 2010 revision).

Say it right, write it right

Core lookup works fully offline, with cloud pronunciation and one-tap save & review. Free, no sign-up.

Free downloadWindowsFree downloadmacOSDownload on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
MobileiOS / Android

Android

QR code for the Google Play pageGet it on Google Play

Scan it with your Android phone to install, or search for “Tomoshi” on Google Play.

iOS

QR code for the App Store pageDownload on the App Store

Scan it with your iPhone camera to install, or search for “Tomoshi” in the App Store.

Install the browser extensionLook words up on any web page · Chrome / Edge / Safari

Screenshot of a Tomoshi lookup resultScreenshot of Tomoshi lookup results on a phone

Windows macOS Chrome / Edge / Safari extension iOS / Android